Thursday, June 14, 2012

Assignment 2 - Edmund Burke


Edmund Burke-The Sublime
Aesthetics class
Kerry Keith Murdock

I believe Edmund Burke is trying to depict the difference between what a normal man or situation would be considered ‘beautiful, verses the incredible, awe-inspiring moments that are rare, in the which he would personally consider a type of true beauty. These occurrences in nature, however, are rare, As it was mentioned in last week’s discussion, the two examples that happened upon my memory were vivid moments from “Jurassic Park” and the climatic space-scene from Jodie Foster’s “Contact.” It seems that Hollywood movie makers are constantly vying for this type of beauty, both for it’s shock-and-awe values but also for the artistic quality in which the scene can be rendered. George Lucas’ ILM (Industrial Lights and Magic) company have been creating such scenes for decades, wowing the audiences with giant, transforming robots, horrible cataclysms, and space-venturing war crafts. The movie make Roland Emmerich, director  of “Independence Day,” has made a career of disaster films with such intended themes in them. The ‘shock and awe’ campaigns become so strong the special effects themselves become the main characters, and the actors with speaking roles become background plot vehicles intended to only take us to the next ‘shock and awe’ scene.
            Again, as mentioned above, outside of fiction these scenarios are relatively few, given one and their location. A certain resident of Hawaii, Florida, or the Philippians may feel they are frequented by hurricanes far too often for their tastes, even if they are visited by only one.
            Aside from this, I believe that Edmund Burke is confusing the term beauty with terrifying. While a disastrous scene before me, such as a car crash, can certainly make me have respect for motor vehicle safety regulations I can in no ways find any gore of a human being in such pain or peril as being beautiful. The great white shark, while certainly hailed as the King of the Great Deep, can no more purge from my lips the summons of the word beautiful than can a stabbing serial killer. Both are to be respected, but in the avenue of fear, not admiration.
            Now let us consider, as I mentioned in our discussion last week, the nature scenes that so many outdoorsy people and photographers enjoy. In these locations there is a tranquil, peaceful, getting-away-from-it-all feeling. To me, far from the comforts of modern living, this might be one of the locations most associated with a type of disaster that would be considered ‘awe-inspiring.’ However, the mood and feeling of these locations are, for the most part, completely different from the shock-and-amaze campaigns described by Burke. So, it is the simple beauty I believe that most people can attribute to with the most frequency. It is relatable, and most often, not nearly as far as one’s backyard, deck porch, or imagination.
            Also, why is it on 3 day holiday weekend vacations, during the hot, summer months, that people throw just a few, scant belongings into the back of a vehicle and break said motor vehicle safety regulations in regard to excess speeding limits to spend as much time as possible in the locations of such quaint, inadequate, and primitive, locations? Again, as I said, ‘to get away from it all.’ So, certain feelings can be ascribed to the nature of beauty. No pun intended. These can include, but are not limited to, happiness, peace, serenity, joy, and love.
            If Burke is still willing to disagree with me regarding this, and his description of beauty in regards to his safety, then may I suggest that the panoramic view of a mountainous vista may be considered beautiful to many, which he could appreciate it by hanging from the tips of his fingers from one of its many, high ledges. Furthermore, the majority of the world’s populace might better appreciate the blossoming buds of a flower’s petals from a distance while he can enjoy it’s many, simple splendors by having a 10,000 pounds of the petals dumped upon him all at once.

Assignment 1 - Plato


Plato
Aesthetics
Kerry Keith Murdock

I believe that Plato’s intentions are to break-up the different aspects of the term ‘beauty’ as a way of defining what is beautiful and what is not.
            He breaks it up into the following aspects: Self-predication, form, Independence from particulars, perfection, beauty, permanence, and simplicity.
            It seems to me that his attempt is to define the different aspects of beauty by breaking them up different nouns. That way, he has a more hands-on equation of defining what is beautiful and what is not. He does not take into account the various individuals, their upbringing, background, or experiences. I believe his equation is intended to be so well-defined that it encompasses all aspects of life.
            However, the word ‘beauty’ is categorized as a descriptive term, as opposed to a noun. I believe what he is trying to do would be like trying to define the color ‘red’ without an appropriate basis.
            The question remains as to whether or not ‘beauty’ can be broken up, whether into a group of nouns or a different set of descriptive adjectives. I believe the concept of ‘beauty’ falls into the same category of ‘truth.’ There is one truth, whether or not we want to believe it. The world is round, despite what we believe. It is up to us as to whether or not we choose to accept truth. I believe that real, actual truth comes from the same source; our Creator. It is this same Being who created beauty, as well. This same Being also created each one of us.
            It is my belief that as we enter into this world we are given a balance of energy that starts out pure. We all enter this world with a clean slate. Based on our experiences, choices, or decisions this balance of energy may skew off to one direction or another. As this direction skews or changes, so does our vision or perception of the world and therefore what is beautiful. I don’t think too many adults still get excited at the sight of a babe’s fluffy bunny or child’s mobile, even though they laughed at those things when young. If a person’s views of normality include violence, drugs, and/or psychological abuse then their views of beauty would vary radically from a person whose life includes a happy family, healthy food, and secure life.
            However, whether or not our views are skewed, the truth of actual beauty still remains. I believe mountain ranges, flowers, and visions of nature fall into the category of beauty whether or not we can accept it as such. That is what they were created for. I believe that garbage, polluted rivers, or discarded liter does not fall into the category of beauty.  
It’s just up to us as to whether or not we are going to accept it.